Wiki

What is a Walstad (dirted) tank, and how do you build one?

A Walstad tank is a low-tech planted tank from Diana Walstad's book: organic soil under a sand or gravel cap, dense planting, floating plants, a few small fish and little equipment. Expect an unsettled first few weeks, and plant heavily from day one.

Updated · Scape Eden

What a Walstad tank is

A Walstad tank, also called a dirted tank, is a planted aquarium built on soil instead of plain gravel. The method is named after Diana Walstad, who described it in her book Ecology of the Planted Aquarium. The hobby guides we read agree on the same few features:

  • Organic soil as the bottom layer, covered by a cap of sand or fine gravel.
  • Dense planting from the start, including fast growers and floating plants.
  • No CO₂ injection, little or no fertiliser in the water, and light filtration.
  • A small number of small fish, shrimp or snails.

The idea, as Wikipedia puts it, is that plants do the water-cleansing job a filter normally does, using what fish waste there is as fertiliser. Treat that as a description of how the method is meant to work, not a promise. Most of what is written about it comes from hobby guides and shop blogs rather than trials, and they disagree on many details. Where they do, this guide gives a range and says so.

It is also one low-tech method among several. If you only want to skip CO₂, the planted tank without CO₂ guide covers the wider choices, and a conventional soil or gravel tank is not wrong. Nothing here is a rule that a planted tank must be dirted.

How it differs from an aqua soil tank and a gravel tank

  • Aqua soil is a packaged product made for aquariums. A dirted tank uses ordinary organic potting soil, chosen with care, and hides it under a cap. Both can release ammonia early: our ammonia spike guide lists new aquasoil as a cause, and the dirted guides we read describe the same thing for fresh soil. Both also run down in time (see worn-out soil).
  • A bare gravel or sand tank has almost nothing in the substrate for roots to eat. Rooted plants then depend on fish waste, root tabs or fertiliser in the water (see the fertiliser calculator). That is simple and predictable.

Our substrate calculator is built around packaged aquarium soil, but it still gives a sensible litre figure for a layer of soil of any kind. Size the tank itself first with the tank volume calculator.

Choosing the soil

Soil is the one place to be strict. Four of the guides we read say to use plain organic soil without additives such as fertiliser or pesticide, and two say to avoid perlite (one also names compost, the other vermiculite). One advises sifting out large pieces of wood, because they rot and add ammonia. Read the ingredients on the bag, look for slow-release fertiliser granules, and put back any bag that lists additives you cannot identify. Products differ from country to country, so labels, not brand names, are what matter.

Building the layers

  1. Set up the empty tank, and place any stone or wood that needs to sit on the glass.
  2. Spread the soil in an even layer. Most guides put it at about an inch (2 to 3 cm). The range runs from a thin scattering of a quarter inch or less in one guide up to about two inches in another.
  3. Cover it with a cap of sand or fine gravel, roughly an inch or a little more. Guides give anything from half an inch to two inches, and one says at least two. The cap holds the soil down and helps keep the water clear.
  4. Fill slowly and gently. A jet of water digs craters in the cap and can push soil around, as our soil slope slumping guide explains. Keep any slope gentle.
  5. Plant through the cap so roots can reach the soil, then add floating plants.
  6. Hold off on fish until a test shows no ammonia (see the next sections).

The step-by-step order, from hardscape to lighting, is the same as in how to set up a planted tank. Only the substrate differs. The first planted tank shopping list shows what else you will need.

Planting heavily, and floating plants

Most guides stress heavy planting from day one. Plants use up the ammonia and nutrients that would otherwise feed algae, which is why too few plants at the start is a common cause of early algae. Fill as much of the floor as you can, and use floating plants as a quick start because they take nutrients from the water straight away.

  • Floating plants: hornwort (easy, fast growing and no CO₂ needed in our records; it has no true roots, so it can float freely or be loosely anchored) and Amazon frogbit. Red root floater, named by two guides, is rated high light in our record, so it may struggle under a dim lamp.
  • Rooted plants that feed through their roots: Wendt's crypt, Beckett's crypt, Amazon sword, and vallisneria. Crypts, swords and vallisneria are each named by at least two guides.
  • Easy plants for wood and stone: java fern and anubias, both rated easy with low light in our records.
  • Fast stem plant to soak up nutrients: anacharis, named by two guides.

Two guides warn that demanding carpet plants and bright-light stems are poor fits for a Walstad setup. That fits our records, where glossostigma, a typical hard carpet plant, needs high light and CO₂. Use the plant finder to filter by light and CO₂, and see the best beginner plants for a broader list.

The early weeks

Fresh soil breaks down and releases nutrients, and one guide describes an early ammonia spike from it, much as our records describe for new aquasoil. Plan for an adjustment period instead of treating it as a fault. How long it lasts varies, and the guides disagree: one reports tanks finishing cycling in as little as a week, another advises waiting one to two weeks, and two say about three to four weeks (one of them allows snails in the first week). Test the water for ammonia and nitrite and let the results, not the calendar, decide.

Fish added while ammonia is high are at risk of poisoning. That is the situation described in new tank syndrome, and the cycling steps in how to cycle a new tank apply here too. If a test shows ammonia, read the ammonia spike guide first. Two guides advise frequent small water changes in the first weeks to keep ammonia and algae down, then fewer once the tank settles. The water change calculator helps with the arithmetic.

Stocking and lighting

Several guides agree on stocking lightly: a small number of small, peaceful fish, plus shrimp and snails. Use the tank-mates tool to check compatibility, and see shrimp-safe fish and plants if you want shrimp.

On lighting, the guides we read say moderate light. They disagree on timing: suggestions include a single block of around eight hours, a longer block, and a split day with a midday break. The lighting schedule guide explains how to choose, the light finder matches a lamp to your tank, and the lighting section lists fittings. Two guides mention window sunlight, but our green water guide lists direct sunlight as a cause of green water, so be careful with it. On filtration, the method calls for little, yet several guides still recommend a small filter or some water movement; see filtration and flow and the filter flow calculator.

What goes wrong

  • Cloudy water: several guides link this to disturbed soil, which a good cap should prevent. Water that turns milky in a new tank can also be a bacteria bloom; see cloudy white water.
  • Algae in the first weeks: two guides expect algae in the early months. More plants, floating plants and less light help. The types of aquarium algae guide shows what you are looking at.
  • Green water: a cloud of free-floating algae, often linked to strong light or overfeeding. See green water.
  • Soil slumping: if you built a slope, the cap can slide. See soil slope slumping.
  • Yellowing or stalled plants once the tank is established: read plants turning yellow or brown.

When the soil is spent

Published estimates of how long dirted soil lasts differ widely. One guide written for a hot climate says 12 to 18 months before the soil's nutrients start to run low, while two other sources say five to ten years, so we do not give a figure. One of those (Aquarium Science) says the decline is the soil's decomposing material being used up rather than its nutrients. We found that view in that one source only, so treat the cause as unsettled.

Our worn-out soil record, written for packaged aquarium soil, suggests root tabs and fertiliser in the water as a first fix; the fertiliser calculator can help. If a tank stays weak, replanting in fresh soil is the other option, and it means taking the tank apart.

Is it for you?

A dirted tank suits someone who wants few gadgets, enjoys dense planting and will accept a slow, slightly messy start. It suits less well if you want to move plants and stone often, because digging stirs the soil under the cap. If you would rather start with a conventional substrate and add equipment as you learn, the beginner aquascaping guide is a better first read. Either way, patience in the first weeks is what matters most.

Keep reading

Sources

We read these pages and wrote the guide in our own words. Species, problem and tool details come from our own wiki pages linked above.

  • Wikipedia: Planted aquarium: Describes the Walstad method as popularised by Diana Walstad: soil, no CO₂ apparatus, most filtration removed, plants using fish waste as fertiliser; second source only
  • Buce Plant: the Walstad method tank guide: Soil under a sand or gravel cap, soil cautions (sift out wood), plant lists including floaters, moderate light, small fish and shrimp, about four weeks before fish, filter or circulation, and cloudy water from disturbed soil
  • Gensou: Walstad method guide: Soil and cap in centimetres, soils to avoid, heavy planting, ammonia from fresh soil and early algae, frequent early water changes; soil lifespan given for a warm climate
  • Fish Tank Advisor: Walstad method: Soil and cap depths, avoid contaminated or pesticide-treated soil, medium light, stem and carpet plants that need bright light and CO₂ do poorly
  • Aquarium Science: Walstad aquarium: Soil and cap depths, small number of small fish, split-day lighting, and the view that decline in old soil is loss of decomposing material; soil lasting five to ten years
  • Aruljohn: 20 gallon Walstad tank: A worked example: soil and cap about an inch to an inch and a half each, Amazon frogbit, anacharis, Amazon sword, vallisneria, java fern and anubias, three to four weeks before fish
  • Nano Haven: the Walstad method: Plant list (hornwort, Amazon sword, vallisneria, frogbit, crypts, anubias) and cap depth of 1 to 1.5 inches
  • Furry Critter: dirt tank overview: An inch of soil under one to two inches of cap, root-feeding plants, and soil lasting five to ten years
  • Aquarium Co-Op: Walstad method: A retailer's outlier view: a very thin layer of dirt under a cap of at least two inches
  • Wikipedia: Ceratophyllum demersum: Hornwort has no true roots and is free floating, though it may attach to the substrate or objects; second source only
  • Betta Botanicals: guide to a dirted aquarium: Dirted tank as soil capped in sand or fine gravel; soil and cap depths; avoid compost, perlite and slow-release fertiliser; nutrients released by the soil, frequent small water changes early on, cycling in as little as a week; floating plants

How we made this

Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them. Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages