What is safe to keep with shrimp? Fish, snails and plants, rated from our data
Almost nothing is guaranteed. Small algae grazers such as otocinclus are the safest fish, and copper is the hidden killer. In our study of 395 fish, only 10% show no shrimp risk, even for baby shrimp.
What our shrimp ratings mean
Every fish record in the wiki holds two shrimp ratings, one for adult shrimp and one for young shrimp (shrimplets). Each is good, caution or avoid. In plain words: no risk recorded, risky, or unsafe. Our shrimp-safety study counts all 395 fish records, and the result is blunt. Only 38 fish (10%) show no shrimp risk even for baby shrimp. 168 (43%) are recorded as eating or threatening adult shrimp, and 357 (90%) put shrimplets at risk.
Good means that no predation is recorded. It is not a promise, because individual fish vary. Not every rating has been checked twice. 54 of the 395 are confirmed by two independent sources, 44 have only one usable source and the rest have not been independently checked yet. Every fish named below comes from the confirmed 54, so these are the ratings we trust most.
These ratings are drafts. The records are written with AI help and checked against their cited sources, but no expert has reviewed them yet, so some may be wrong. The study page explains the method, lists the limits and links the free CSV. See also how the records are written and checked.
Rules of thumb that hold up
- Mouth size matters most. A fish that can fit a shrimp in its mouth may eat it. A peaceful fish too small to swallow an adult can still eat a newborn shrimplet.
- Size is a strong signal. In our data, 79 of the 89 fish that reach 20 cm or more (89%) are recorded as eating adult shrimp, and so are 71 of 104 at 10 to 19.9 cm (68%). Fish under 5 cm rarely eat adults (1 of 73, with 12 more recorded as a risk), but 51 of those 73 are recorded as a risk to shrimplets only. Small is not a pass.
- Hunters are obvious. None of the 103 cichlid records is free of shrimp risk, and all 21 records in the predator group are recorded as eating adult shrimp. Browse the fish pages before you buy anything big.
- Bottom feeders are not automatically safe. Corydoras and kuhli loaches search the bottom for small food, and they will eat shrimplets they find. When we re-checked several Corydoras and Boraras rasboras against two sources, their young-shrimp rating moved from good to caution.
- Expect shrimplet losses with most fish: 90% of the fish in our data put shrimplets at risk. If you want a colony that grows, keep shrimp alone or give them heavy cover.
- Cover matters. Moss, fine plants and gaps in the hardscape give shrimplets and moulting shrimp somewhere to hide, and Practical Fishkeeping notes that plenty of hiding places reduce losses.
- Add shrimp first. Practical Fishkeeping advises letting the shrimp colony build up before you add any fish.
- Individual fish vary, and a record describes the usual case.
Examples by rating
Each fish below has its rating confirmed by two independent sources in our records.
- Unsafe (adults rated avoid): pictus catfish, hoplo catfish, three-spot gourami, firemouth cichlid, tinfoil barb and Delhezi bichir. The records say they eat shrimp.
- Risky (adults rated caution): zebra danio, swordtail, rainbow shark, Chinese algae eater and lemon tetra. They eat shrimplets and may take adults.
- Adults fine, shrimplets at risk: chili rasbora, ember tetra, dwarf cory, kuhli loach and Vietnamese cloud minnow. Fine for a mixed tank if you do not need baby shrimp to survive.
- No shrimp risk recorded: otocinclus, butterfly hillstream loach and twig catfish. Several large plecos are also rated good, but they outgrow a shrimp tank.
Otocinclus are small sucker-mouthed algae grazers, which fits the mouth-size rule. Keep them in a group in a mature tank, as their record explains, because many arrive underfed. To shortlist fish for your tank size, use the tank mates tool. If a fish starts nipping fins instead, see fin nipping and bullying.
Snails and other shrimp
Snails are the usual companions. Zebra nerites and horned nerites graze algae. Nerite eggs do not hatch in fresh water because the larvae need brackish or salt water, so numbers stay under control. Malaysian trumpet snails are live-bearers that multiply with the food supply. Assassin snails hunt other snails, and some keepers report that they also take shrimplets, so think twice before adding them to a breeding shrimp colony.
Other shrimp suit shrimp tanks too. The bamboo shrimp is peaceful, but it filter-feeds, so it needs strong flow and fine food in the water. Browse the full invertebrate section. Keep species with matching water needs together (see the hard and soft water section below).
Plants that help shrimp
Shrimp keepers commonly use plants that give cover and a surface where biofilm grows for shrimp to graze. Most are easy and need no added CO₂ (see the low-tech planted tank guide).
- Java moss and Singapore moss: the classic shrimplet hideout. Tie a clump to wood or rock.
- Java fern and Anubias nana: tough, slow plants that keepers often use for cover and grazing surfaces. Keep the rhizome above the substrate.
- Amazon frogbit, water spangles and water lettuce: floating plants that keepers use for shade and hiding places among their hanging roots.
- Guppy grass: a fast stem plant, often used for fine cover and nutrient uptake.
Filter all plants by light and difficulty with the plant finder, or browse the plant pages. Buy new plants from a seller who can say how they were grown. Practical Fishkeeping traced sudden shrimp deaths to pesticide residues on imported mail-order plants, so ask the seller, rinse well and keep new plants in a separate tub for a while before they go into a shrimp tank.
What harms shrimp besides fish
Copper is the big one. Shrimp are far more sensitive to it than fish, and most invertebrates cannot survive copper treatments. It turns up in some fish medicines, some plant fertilisers, some fish foods and, in some homes, copper pipes. Read the label of every medicine, food and fertiliser for copper before it goes near a shrimp tank. If you cannot tell, ask the maker or an aquatic vet. We give no doses here. Move a sick fish to a separate tank rather than medicating the shrimp tank. Use the fertiliser tool to plan nutrients, and still check the label. If shrimp die suddenly while fish look fine, see sudden shrimp deaths.
Sudden change is the second killer. Abrupt shifts in pH, hardness (GH, KH) or dissolved solids (TDS) can force a shrimp to moult early, and a failed moult is often fatal. Keep water changes small and regular, with treated, temperature-matched water (the water change calculator helps, and chlorine and chloramine explains why treating tap water matters). Add new shrimp with a slow drip, not a quick float of the bag. See deaths after new fish, pH swings and failed moult. Leave shed shells in the tank, because shrimp eat them.
Hard water or soft water?
Water needs split shrimp into two broad groups. Red cherry shrimp and blue pearl shrimp are adaptable and tolerate more dissolved minerals. Bee and crystal shrimp such as Caridina logemanni need soft, mineral-poor water and tolerate less. The Amano shrimp has its own range, shown on its record. Nerite snails prefer harder water, and soft acidic water erodes their shells. The exact ranges are on each record.
Shrimp keepers agree that stability matters more than hitting a textbook number. Ask the seller what water the shrimp were raised in and compare it with yours before you buy.
A safe order of work
- Choose the shrimp first, using your tap water and the matching invertebrate page.
- Set the tank up and let it cycle before any animal goes in (see how to cycle a new tank). Shrimp are very sensitive to ammonia and nitrite (see ammonia spike).
- Plant heavily, with moss and floating plants, before the shrimp arrive.
- Add the shrimp slowly and let the colony settle.
- If you want fish, pick ones with the best ratings in the examples above, and check them in the tank mates tool.
- Keep medicines out of the tank until you have read the label for copper.
For more setups, see all the wiki guides. To check a specific fish, open its record. Every record shows its two shrimp ratings, and the study page links the CSV for all 395.
Keep reading
Sources
We read these pages and wrote the guide in our own words. Species, problem and tool details come from our own wiki pages linked above.
- Scape Eden shrimp-safety study (395 fish records): All counts and percentages, the rating categories, the two-source check status and the limits
- Scape Eden shrimp-safety data (CSV, CC BY 4.0): Per-fish ratings, evidence status and sources behind each fish named above
- Practical Fishkeeping: What can I keep with shrimp?: Mouth size, hunters to avoid, hiding places reduce losses, settling the colony first
- Practical Fishkeeping: How to acclimatise your new fish or shrimp: Drip acclimation for shrimp, which are sensitive to changes in water chemistry
- Practical Fishkeeping: pfk investigates shrimps killed by mail order plants: Pesticide residues on imported plants killing shrimp; quarantine and rinsing advice
- Practical Fishkeeping: Fans of flow, keeping bamboo shrimp: Bamboo shrimp are peaceful filter feeders that need strong flow and fine food
- Shrimp and Snail Breeder: red cherry shrimp: Predatory fish to avoid, snail tank mates, moss and floating plants for cover, copper in some foods and medicines
- Shrimp and Snail Breeder: moulting problems: Abrupt water changes and unstable conditions forcing early or failed moults
- Shrimp and Snail Breeder: TDS in shrimp tanks: Neocaridina are more adaptable than bee and crystal shrimp; stability over chasing numbers
- Shrimp and Snail Breeder: nerite snails: Nerite eggs need brackish water to hatch; nerites prefer harder water and soft acidic water erodes shells
- Shrimp and Snail Breeder: how copper affects dwarf shrimp: Copper sources: medicines, copper pipes, some fertilisers and fish foods
- ShrimpKeepers: water parameter changes (GH): Sudden parameter swings can cause failed moults and death; change gradually
- ShrimpKeepers: nitrite in shrimp tanks: Shrimp have very little tolerance for ammonia and nitrite
- Wikipedia: Vittina natalensis (zebra nerite): Reproduces only in brackish or salt water
- ShrimpKeepers: TDS for shrimp: Neocaridina tolerate higher dissolved solids than Caridina; change water parameters gradually
- UF/IFAS Extension: copper treatment (FA165): Most invertebrates cannot survive copper; move them out before any copper treatment
- Furry Critter: copper toxicity from medications and pipes: Copper sources: fish medicines, plumbing, some plant fertilisers
- Wikipedia: Taxiphyllum barbieri (Java moss): Moss as shelter for young animals and a surface that collects food for shrimp
- Wikipedia: Neocaridina davidi: Shrimp eat their shed shells, so moults should stay in the tank
- Scape Eden shrimp, snail and plant records: Snail behaviour, water ranges and plant traits, from the records linked above
How we made this
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them. Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages
