Wiki

Planted tank without CO₂: a low-tech setup and the best plants

Yes, a planted tank works without added CO₂ if you choose plants that do not need it, keep the light low at 6 to 8 hours a day and change about 20 to 25% of the water each week. Extra light without extra CO₂ mostly grows algae.

Updated · Scape Eden

What a low-tech tank is

A low-tech planted tank has no injected CO₂ and often little or no liquid fertiliser. The plants get their carbon from the water, where fish breathing and the surface add a little. Growth is slower than in a CO₂ tank, you have fewer plants to choose from and there is a much smaller margin for strong light.

Plants split into easy and demanding groups. Easy plants grow without added CO₂, though they usually do better with it. Demanding plants such as HC Cuba, Glossostigma and Rotala macrandra need strong light and injected CO₂. If you want a carpet or red stems, plan CO₂ from the start. If not, this guide is the route.

The one rule: match light to carbon

Plants use light, CO₂ and nutrients together. Under medium or strong light, plants use CO₂ faster than it can be replaced from the air, so every plant slows down and algae fills the gap. In a tank with no CO₂, extra light adds algae pressure more than plant growth. The fixes are modest light, a short day and plants that suit the conditions.

  • Choose a light for your water depth. Light fades quickly in water, and a tall tank may need a stronger fitting for the bottom plants. Look at the lighting section for fittings, and read too little light if the lowest plants fade.
  • Run the light on a timer. Start at 6 hours a day for a new tank, and keep it at about 6 to 8 hours once the plants are growing, raising it only if no algae shows. A longer day feeds algae more easily.
  • Float some plants. Amazon frogbit shades the tank and takes up nutrients. Keep it to about half to two-thirds of the surface, net out the extra weekly and bin it, never tipping it into drains or waterways, as it is invasive in many places.
  • Never raise the light without a reason. If you do, raise carbon and nutrients too, or accept algae.

The best plants for a tank with no CO₂

Our records rate these as easy plants that need no added CO₂. Choose a few, repeat them, and leave room to grow.

  • Java fern: up to about 35 cm, slow, low light. Tie it to wood or rock and never bury the rhizome.
  • Anubias nana: about 10 cm, slow, low light. Keep the rhizome above the substrate and out of strong light so algae stays off its slow leaves.
  • Wendt's crypt: about 30 cm, low light. It usually melts after planting and regrows within a few weeks (see crypt melt).
  • Singapore moss: flat mats on wood or rock. Keep the light low to medium.
  • Water wisteria: a fast stem plant up to about 50 cm that takes up nutrients quickly.
  • Hornwort: grows fast, floating or anchored, and slows algae floating in the water.
  • Guppy grass: very easy, very fast, a good filler for a new tank.

Use the plant finder to filter by light, CO₂ and difficulty. For a slow low-tech carpet, dwarf crypt is a better fit than a carpet that wants CO₂, but it grows slowly and wants a little more light than most crypts.

Setting it up

  1. Choose plants first, then the light that suits them. Use the tank volume calculator and the substrate calculator before you buy.
  2. Lay the hardscape, add the substrate and fill slowly onto a plate to keep the layout in place.
  3. Plant densely on day one, with a mix of fast stems and floating plants plus the slow plants you want to keep. Plenty of plants use up the nutrients that algae would take. See the beginner planted tank guide.
  4. Set the light to 6 hours. Let the tank cycle before adding fish (see the cycling guide), and hold off fertiliser at first.
  5. Change about 20 to 25% of the water weekly with treated, temperature-matched water. Low-tech guides suggest anything from 15 to 25%.
  6. Add livestock slowly, a few animals at a time. Shrimp, nerite snails and similar grazers work well in a low-tech tank.

Feeding the plants

Rooted plants feed from the substrate. A nutrient-rich soil feeds rooted plants for the first months and then runs low over time; the pace varies by brand and plant load. Push root tabs in near heavy root feeders such as crypts, and follow the label (see worn-out soil).

Use liquid fertiliser lightly and follow the label. More is not better: if plants cannot use the nutrients, algae will. Keep the dose steady rather than swinging it.

Reading the signs

A low-tech tank tells you early when the balance is off. Match what you see to a guide, and change one thing at a time.

  • Fine green strands on plants and wood: hair algae. Light is running ahead of what the plants can use. Cut the light to 6 to 8 hours and clear the strands by hand.
  • A green haze on the glass that wipes off and returns: green dust algae. It is tied to a young tank and runs its course in a few weeks.
  • Water turning pea-green: green water. Direct sun, overfeeding or a fertiliser overdose are the usual triggers.
  • Oldest leaves turning yellow while new leaves stay green: old leaves turning yellow. In a tank with few fish and little fertiliser, a nitrogen shortage is the usual cause; worn-out soil is another.
  • Pale new leaves with green veins: pale new leaves, most often an iron shortage.

If your demanding plants are melting

HC Cuba, Glossostigma and red stems such as Rotala macrandra slowly thin out, turn pale or leggy and grow algae when there is no added CO₂. Do not raise the light to save them. Pull out the ones that keep declining before they rot, and replace them with easy plants such as Anubias, Java fern, Cryptocoryne, moss or Hygrophila. Check the light first, since weak light can starve even easy plants, and remember that new tissue-culture plants often melt a little and then regrow.

Stocking a low-tech tank

Stock by what the filter and your water changes can handle, and feed sparingly. Add a few animals at a time, wait for the tank to settle, and check adult sizes before you buy. Grazers such as nerite snails and cherry shrimp suit a low-tech tank, but shrimp are more sensitive to poor water than most fish. Use the tank mates calculator to check which fish can share a tank.

Weekly routine

  • Change about 20 to 25% of the water, and top up only with treated water.
  • Feed fish lightly. Extra food adds ammonia and nitrate (see overfeeding).
  • Wipe the glass and remove dead leaves.
  • Trim little and often. Slow plants need less trimming, and big trims can upset the tank's balance, which is why Tropica prefers small, frequent ones (see trimming too much).
  • Do not move plants without a reason. Crypts in particular dislike being dug up.

Common mistakes

When to add CO₂ instead

Consider CO₂ if you want carpet plants or red stem plants, or if you want to run stronger light on a deep tank. It adds cost and risk, since too much CO₂ can suffocate fish. Check the CO₂ equipment and the CO₂ calculator before you decide, and start low-tech first if you are new.

Keep reading

Sources

We read these pages and wrote the guide in our own words. Species, problem and tool details come from our own wiki pages linked above.

How we made this

Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them. Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages