Wiki

Fertilising a planted tank: what plants need and how to dose it

Plants need nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, iron, trace elements and CO₂. Fish waste supplies some of it. Start below the label dose, raise it only as the plants respond, and fix light and CO₂ first, because extra fertiliser under weak growth can feed algae.

Updated · Scape Eden

What plants actually need

Plants build themselves from light, carbon and a short list of dissolved minerals. Rex Grigg's planted-tank notes list carbon (normally as CO₂), nitrogen (normally as nitrate), potassium, phosphorus (normally as phosphate), iron, calcium, magnesium and other trace minerals. Tropica calls CO₂ the most important nutrient, because without it plants cannot photosynthesise, and says that besides CO₂ plants need nitrogen, phosphorus, iron and manganese in relatively large amounts.

Fish are part of the supply. Tropica makes a trace-element fertiliser without nitrogen or phosphorus for tanks with many fish, because fish waste supplies those two. Furrycritter, a hobbyist site, likewise says a tank with many fish often needs little or no added nitrogen, since waste and food supply nitrate and phosphate. A tank with many plants and few fish gets less from this source. A heavily stocked tank can also build up nitrate on its own, see high nitrate.

Water column or roots

Nutrients reach plants two ways, and the right product depends on how the plant feeds.

  • Liquid fertiliser goes into the water. Tropica says it is the only way to feed mosses, floating plants and plants attached to rocks and wood, such as Anubias, because their roots are not in the bottom layer. Dennerle says leaf-feeding plants want liquid fertiliser after every water change.
  • Root tabs and nutrient-rich soils feed through the substrate. Tropica lists stem plants, crypts, Echinodorus and Vallisneria among the users of its root capsules, for example Wendt's crypt and Vallisneria.
  • Aquarium Science would split the job: phosphorus and iron into the substrate, nitrogen and potassium into the water. It also warns that root tabs do little in coarse gravel. Other sources do not make this split, so treat it as one expert's view.

Nutrient soils do not last for ever. Their built-in food is drawn down as plants grow, and root feeders then show shortages even though your dosing has not changed (see worn-out soil). Published timings for root capsules and soils vary from source to source, even between two pages of the same maker, so we give none. Watch the plants instead. Our substrate calculator helps with the amount of soil to buy.

When to start in a new tank

Sources disagree, so here are both. Tropica advises no fertiliser, or a limited amount, for the first 3 to 4 weeks, because nursery-grown plants arrive with enough stored nutrients to root. Dennerle starts earlier: from week 2 at half the recommended dose, reaching the full dose in week 3. Both start gently, and Tropica's care guide adds that you should begin below the label dose and raise it according to how the plants react. See also how to cycle a new tank and the step-by-step set-up.

Three ways people dose

Hobbyists use a few named approaches. We attribute them but give no recipes, because the right amount depends on your light, CO₂, plants and stock.

  • Lean dosing. As Aquarium Lesson explains it, the aim is enough nutrients for healthy growth while keeping some lower, so growth is steadier and algae gets less. Furrycritter adds that it typically cannot meet the demand of a tank with intense light and injected CO₂.
  • Estimative Index (EI). Aquarium Science credits Dr Tom Barr with it. Plants get a generous steady surplus, macro and trace additions alternate through the week, and a large weekly water change (50 per cent in the sources we read) resets the build-up. Aquarium Lesson says it was partly designed to cut testing, and that when CO₂ is low or unstable, extra fertiliser will not fix the limit and can bring algae and poor growth. Aquarium Science's author calls EI somewhat complicated and very time-consuming, and, citing Dr Barr, traces most problems to CO₂ rather than to the fertiliser.
  • All-in-one liquid at label dose. A complete liquid from a planted-tank range is the simplest to use, but Tropica suggests starting below the label dose.

None of these is the single correct method. They trade plant growth against algae risk, effort and cost. If you run no added CO₂, read a planted tank without CO₂ first, since low-tech tanks sit at the lean end.

Target windows and our calculator

Our fertiliser calculator turns weekly targets into dry-salt grams or liquid millilitres for your water volume. Its target windows are nitrate 10 to 20 ppm, phosphate 1 to 2 ppm, potassium 10 to 20 ppm and iron 0.2 to 0.5 ppm per week. They are the overlap of two published sets: Aquarium Science's weekly EI targets (nitrate 5 to 30, phosphate 1 to 2, potassium 10 to 30, iron 0.2 to 0.5 or more) and the levels Rex Grigg suggests keeping in the water (nitrate 10 to 20, phosphate 1 to 2, potassium 10 to 20, iron 0.1 to 1.0). Grigg gives levels rather than weekly totals, so the match is approximate.

Other sources differ. The GWAPA algae article gives nitrate 10 to 20, phosphate 0.5 to 2, potassium 10 to 20 and iron at only about 0.1 ppm, while Aquarium Lesson says EI nitrate is often roughly 20 to 30 ppm per week in high-energy examples. Lean methods aim lower. So treat the window as a cautious middle, not a rule. We give no dose amounts here: the calculator works them out from your volume and your product's label. Use the tank volume calculator first, so you enter real water volume, not the label size of the tank.

Deficiency signs, and why they overlap

Plants complain through their leaves, but the same leaf can have several explanations. Dennerle says deficiency signs usually appear first on the youngest leaves, as stunted growth, discoloured leaves or damaged tissue, and describes iron shortage as pale to yellow leaves with green veins. Tropica says pale leaves often point to a lack of nutrition, and that its fertiliser is not a medicine for dying plants. Aquarium Co-Op describes the same iron pattern, yellowing old leaves for nitrogen (the plant draws it from old leaves) and pinholes for potassium. In our records the pattern is:

The pattern is a guide, not a diagnosis. Crypts can melt after planting for reasons unrelated to fertiliser (see crypt melt), and worn soil looks like a missing nutrient. Change one thing and watch the new growth. Our guide to plants turning yellow or brown sorts the causes in order.

Light and CO₂ decide how much fertiliser works

Nutrients are only one leg of a tripod. Aquarium Science says higher plants typically need light, CO₂ and nutrients in balance and calls CO₂ the most important variable. Aquarium Lesson says stronger light raises plant demand, and unstable or low CO₂ can bring algae and poor growth even when fertiliser is plentiful. Tropica says overfertilising causes algae when plants cannot absorb the fertiliser as it is added. So when growth is slow, more fertiliser is usually the wrong first move.

Too little can cause trouble too. The GWAPA algae article links green spot algae to phosphate that stays low, so the aim is not zero phosphate (see green spot algae). The full picture of causes is in the types of aquarium algae. Water changes are part of any dosing plan: Rex Grigg and Aquarium Lesson both describe the large weekly change (50 per cent in each) as the reset that stops nutrients piling up. Work out your change with the water change calculator and fit dosing into the weekly routine.

Fish and shrimp: read the label

UF/IFAS Extension says most invertebrates, shrimp and snails among them, are highly sensitive to copper, and copper is a trace element some fertilisers contain. JBL, a maker, answers that copper is an essential trace element for plants and animals, and says even a multiple overdose of its own fertilisers does not harm shrimp. That is the maker's claim about its own products only. Aquarium Lesson is more cautious: full-strength EI may be too strong for a lightly planted shrimp tank, and a reduced approach or a shrimp-safe fertiliser is usually more practical. So choose a product whose label says it suits invertebrates and never dose above the label. For plants and fish that suit a shrimp tank, see shrimp-safe fish and plants.

Do you need test kits?

Not strictly: lean and label-dose approaches work from the plants' response. A nitrate and a phosphate kit still show what the tank holds before and after dosing, but treat results as rough (our calculator notes that these kits are only roughly accurate). Aquarium Science also points out that kits and scientific papers can report nitrate differently, as NO₃ or as nitrogen only (NO₃-N), so the numbers differ by a factor of about 4.4. Check the unit before comparing a reading with a target.

A sensible order of work

  1. Plant densely and settle light and CO₂ first, see the shopping list and beginner plant picks.
  2. Choose a product to fit the tank: trace elements only for a fish-heavy tank, a complete liquid for a plant-heavy one, root tabs for root feeders.
  3. Start below the label dose and let new growth show whether to raise it.
  4. Keep water changes regular, and test nitrate and phosphate now and then.
  5. Change one thing at a time. The plant finder picks plants that match the light and CO₂ you can give.

Keep reading

Sources

We read these pages and wrote the guide in our own words. Species, problem and tool details come from our own wiki pages linked above.

How we made this

Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them. Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages