Best beginner fish for a planted tank: 18 easy, plant-safe picks from our records
Choose small, peaceful fish that leave plants alone: neon, ember or harlequin schoolers, corydoras, kuhli loaches, guppies, or one betta or honey gourami. Our records narrow 395 fish to 87 that fit. Cycle the tank first, then add fish a few at a time.
How we picked these fish
Most first-fish lists are one writer's favourites. This one starts from our 395 fish records and keeps a fish only if it passes four filters, applied in this order:
- Difficulty rated easy: 209 of the 395 fish.
- Plant safety rated good, meaning no serious plant damage is recorded: 149 of those 209.
- Adult size 8 cm or less, so the tank does not need to be huge: 91 of those 149.
- A recorded temperature range that includes 24 °C, so one heater setting suits the whole group: 87 fish.
We then picked 18 by role, favouring peaceful fish that do not nip, and checking the best-known ones against SeriouslyFish and Wikipedia. Three fish miss a filter on purpose and are flagged where they appear: otocinclus (rated medium), the kuhli loach (10 cm) and the bristlenose (15 cm). These records are drafts that no expert has reviewed yet (how the records are written), so check a fish's page before you buy. Browse all of them in the fish section.
Rules that matter more than the species
- Cycle the tank before any fish go in. Our guide to cycling a new tank explains how, and ammonia spike shows what goes wrong when a tank is rushed.
- Add fish in stages. The RSPCA knowledge base advises against adding large numbers of fish at once, because the filter bacteria need time to adapt. Start with one group, test the water, then add the next. Overstocking and deaths after new fish cover the usual results of skipping this.
- Acclimatise gently. Practical Fishkeeping recommends floating the bag and mixing in small amounts of tank water before netting the fish across, and keeping transport water out of the tank.
- Buy groups of the schooling fish. SeriouslyFish advises 8 to 10 neon tetras, harlequin rasboras or ember tetras. Wikipedia sets the floor lower, at 6, and for ember tetras recommends 9 to 10. Read that as a minimum of about six and a better target of eight to ten.
- Size the tank for the adults. Use the tank volume tool to check your litres, and the tank mates tool to see what suits that volume.
- Use a lid with a small gap below it. SeriouslyFish notes that the fish sold as kuhli loaches jump, and that bettas need access to the humid air above the water.
- Match the temperature. A heater holds one setting for everyone; see heating and cooling equipment.
Small schooling fish for the middle of the tank
These are the classic planted-tank fish. They stay small, ignore plants and show their colour against green.
- Neon tetra: 3 to 4 cm and peaceful. SeriouslyFish gives 21 to 25 °C and Wikipedia 22 to 24 °C. SeriouslyFish says it does best in dim light, with plants such as Java fern, Cryptocoryne and floating plants.
- Ember tetra: 2 to 3 cm, peaceful and best in a heavily planted tank. Both sources say larger tankmates stress it.
- Harlequin rasbora: about 4.5 cm, very peaceful. SeriouslyFish suggests plants for dim light such as Anubias and Cryptocoryne.
- Glowlight tetra: peaceful and shoaling according to Wikipedia, roughly 3.5 to 5 cm depending on the source, and easy in our records. Its glowing line shows best in subdued light over a dark base.
- Black neon tetra: about 3.5 to 4 cm and very peaceful according to SeriouslyFish, which says it likes dense planting. Easy in our records, and a good alternative to the neon.
- Cherry barb: about 5 cm and peaceful according to SeriouslyFish and Wikipedia, and easy in our records. Wikipedia advises at least two females per male.
Bottom dwellers and algae eaters
Bottom fish tidy leftover food and add movement low in the tank. SeriouslyFish recommends sand for corydoras because they root through it for food, and for kuhli loaches because they like to dig. Our records note that both can dislodge small, newly planted plants, so let roots establish first.
- Peppered cory: about 7 cm. Wikipedia calls it relatively hardy and peaceful, and SeriouslyFish agrees it is peaceful. Keep a group.
- Julii cory: about 5.5 cm. SeriouslyFish and our record both say many fish sold under this name are look-alikes, so check the page for the spot pattern.
- Panda cory: about 5 cm. SeriouslyFish calls it very peaceful and a good first catfish.
- Pygmy cory: about 3 cm and swims in midwater. SeriouslyFish advises at least 6 and preferably 10 or more, and says larger tankmates easily intimidate it.
- Kuhli loach: about 10 cm (one of our filter exceptions). Fish sold under this name are usually Pangio semicincta, a close relative, because SeriouslyFish and Wikipedia both say the true Pangio kuhlii is rarely if ever kept. Wikipedia calls the loach nocturnal and shy and advises groups of 5 or more, with places to burrow and hide such as wood and plants. SeriouslyFish advises 5 or 6 on soft sand and a tight lid, because the species jumps; that advice comes from its P. semicincta page.
- Otocinclus: small algae grazers, roughly 3.5 to 5.5 cm depending on the species, rated medium in our records (an exception). Wikipedia says mostly wild-caught fish reach hobbyists, and SeriouslyFish says they starve easily in transport, so add them only to a mature planted tank with soft algae to graze.
- Bristlenose pleco: about 15 cm in our records and up to 15 cm for males according to Wikipedia (an exception). It grazes algae and biofilm and also eats vegetables. It needs a bigger tank than the fish above.
Centrepiece fish
A single eye-catching fish can anchor a small planted tank. The betta breathes air at the surface, so keep a gap under the lid. SeriouslyFish advises floating plants for honey gouramis.
- Betta: about 7 cm. Wikipedia says males are best kept apart, and SeriouslyFish says it is best kept alone, with only a few species ever working as tankmates. SeriouslyFish says to avoid tankmates with trailing fins, and Wikipedia adds that it attacks smaller, slower fish such as guppies. It is a good fit for a calm species tank.
- Honey gourami: about 5.5 cm by both sources. It is peaceful and easily intimidated, so SeriouslyFish advises calm tankmates and dense planting with floating plants. Males can be territorial toward each other, according to Wikipedia.
Livebearers
Livebearers are hardy and active, and they prefer harder water than most tetras and rasboras. They breed freely, so plan what to do with the young before you buy.
- Guppy: both sources describe it as peaceful and fond of hard water. SeriouslyFish advises several females to each male, because males harass females. Wikipedia notes that males sometimes nip each other and top-swimming fish.
- Endler's livebearer: SeriouslyFish gives up to about 2.5 cm and 24 to 30 °C, and advises several females per male (Wikipedia says females grow up to twice the size of males).
- Least killifish: SeriouslyFish calls it the smallest known livebearer, very peaceful but not a community fish, and recommends a heavily planted tank. Wikipedia gives about 2 cm for males and 3 cm for females.
The southern platy is also easy and very peaceful according to SeriouslyFish. Our record flags soft-plant nibbling, which we could not confirm with a second source, so it is not on the list.
What to avoid at first
The worst first-tank mistakes are fish that eat or uproot plants, fish that outgrow the tank, and fish that bully. In our records 55 of the 395 fish are rated avoid for plant safety.
- Plant eaters. Tropica advises that goldfish and some cichlids need tough, strong-tasting plants, and Wikipedia states that goldfish make a planted aquarium problematic. SeriouslyFish calls the silver dollar an avid plant eater, and Wikipedia describes the silver dollar genus as largely herbivorous. Goldfish are listed in our records as eating soft plants and uprooting them.
- Diggers and bullies. SeriouslyFish says the oscar tends to dig into the substrate and suits a carefully aquascaped tank poorly. It calls the convict cichlid an avid digger that may uproot plants, violent when breeding and not a good community fish.
- Fish that outgrow the tank. The common pleco grows far larger than most home tanks allow: Wikipedia gives a maximum of 43 cm standard length, and our record gives about 50 cm.
- Fin nippers. SeriouslyFish and Wikipedia both describe the tiger barb as a fin nipper, and SeriouslyFish calls it a poor companion for timid, slow or long-finned species. Even so, it passes our four filters, so check behaviour as well as the filters. See fin nipping and bullying.
Most of the fish above are peaceful, but even peaceful fish can be intimidated. Honey gouramis and ember tetras both do badly beside boisterous or much larger fish.
Compatibility and shrimp
Pick fish that want the same water and temperament, and that cannot swallow each other. The tank mates tool helps shortlist fish for your tank size. Do not mix a boisterous fish with a timid one, and do not put two male bettas in one tank.
If you want shrimp too, our shrimp-safety study rates every fish for adult and young shrimp. Only ratings confirmed by two independent sources are quoted here. The ember tetra, peppered cory and julii cory are rated good for adult shrimp and caution for young ones. The kuhli loach is good for adults and avoid for young, and otocinclus is good for both. The other fish here have no confirmed rating, so we make no claim. Read the shrimp-safe guide before mixing.
Where to go next
- Plan the whole purchase with the first planted tank shopping list and the step-by-step setup guide.
- Choose plants with the best beginner plants and the plant finder.
- Avoid common errors in beginner aquascaping mistakes.
- Keep water clean with the weekly routine and the water change tool.
Keep reading
Sources
We read these pages and wrote the guide in our own words. Species, problem and tool details come from our own wiki pages linked above.
- SeriouslyFish: Paracheirodon innesi (neon tetra): Size, 21 to 25 C, group of 8 to 10, dim light, plants
- SeriouslyFish: Trigonostigma heteromorpha (harlequin rasbora): Size, group of 8 to 10, very peaceful, broad-leaved plants
- SeriouslyFish: Hyphessobrycon amandae (ember tetra): Size, group of 8 to 10, will not compete with larger tankmates, heavily planted tank
- SeriouslyFish: Poecilia reticulata (guppy): Several females per male, hard water, prolific breeding
- SeriouslyFish: Poecilia wingei (Endler's livebearer): Size and several females per male
- SeriouslyFish: Betta splendens: Best kept alone, labyrinth organ, avoid trailing-finned tankmates
- SeriouslyFish: Trichogaster chuna (honey gourami): Peaceful and easily intimidated, group advice, planting
- SeriouslyFish: Corydoras paleatus (peppered cory): Size, peaceful, sand substrate
- SeriouslyFish: Pangio semicincta (the fish usually sold as kuhli loach): Page covers P. semicincta: soft sand, tight lid, group of five or six, true P. kuhlii rarely kept
- SeriouslyFish: Metynnis argenteus (silver dollar): Avid plant eater, large group tank
- SeriouslyFish: Puntigrus tetrazona (tiger barb): Fin biting and poor tankmate for timid or long-finned fish
- Wikipedia: Neon tetra: Size, 22 to 24 C, groups of at least six
- Wikipedia: Harlequin rasbora: Size, temperature, minimum group of six, peaceful
- Wikipedia: Ember tetra: Group of at least six, stressed by larger fish, planted tank
- Wikipedia: Siamese fighting fish: Males best isolated, labyrinth organ, size
- Wikipedia: Guppy: Size, hard water, shoaling, nipping between males
- Wikipedia: Honey gourami: Size, peaceful, male territoriality, dense planting
- Wikipedia: Corydoras paleatus: Size and hardy, peaceful temperament
- Wikipedia: Kuhli loach: Size, groups of five or more, nocturnal, substrate
- Wikipedia: Otocinclus: Algae grazers, mostly wild caught
- Wikipedia: Goldfish: Goldfish eat live plants, a problem in planted aquariums
- Wikipedia: Amazon sailfin catfish: Maximum 43 cm standard length
- Tropica: Make your aquarium a success: Goldfish and some cichlids eat plants; choose tough plants
- RSPCA Knowledge Base: water quality when setting up an aquarium: Do not add many fish at once; introduce gradually
- Practical Fishkeeping: How to acclimatise your new fish or shrimp: Float acclimation, keep transport water out of the tank
- SeriouslyFish: Hoplisoma julii (julii cory): Size, look-alikes, peaceful
- SeriouslyFish: Hoplisoma panda (panda cory): Size, very peaceful, good for newcomers
- SeriouslyFish: Corydoras pygmaeus (pygmy cory): Size, midwater, group of 6 to 10 or more
- SeriouslyFish: Hyphessobrycon herbertaxelrodi (black neon tetra): Size, very peaceful, dense planting
- SeriouslyFish: Puntius titteya (cherry barb): Size, peaceful, group of 6 to 10
- SeriouslyFish: Heterandria formosa (least killifish): Smallest livebearer, not a community fish, heavy planting
- SeriouslyFish: Otocinclus macrospilus: Wild-caught, starve in transport, mature tank
- SeriouslyFish: Astronotus ocellatus (oscar): Digs into the substrate
- SeriouslyFish: Amatitlania nigrofasciata (convict cichlid): Avid digger, violent when breeding
- Wikipedia: Tiger barb: Known fin nippers
- Wikipedia: Metynnis: Silver dollars are herbivorous or omnivorous
- Wikipedia: Glowlight tetra: Size 4 to 5 cm, peaceful, shoaling
- Wikipedia: Black neon tetra: Size, peaceful
- Wikipedia: Cherry barb: Size, two females per male
- Wikipedia: Least killifish: Male 2 cm, female 3 cm
- Wikipedia: Endler's livebearer: Females up to twice the size of males
- Wikipedia: Ancistrus: Size up to 15 cm, algae and vegetable diet, peaceful
- Scape Eden fish records and shrimp-safety study: Filter counts, sizes, ratings and the two-source confirmation status
How we made this
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them. Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages
