Carpet plants compared: which one to choose, from easiest to hardest
For a first carpet without CO₂, Tropica rates dwarf hairgrass and Marsilea hirsuta easy, with low light and low CO₂. Monte Carlo is the usual next step. HC Cuba and glosso come last: Tropica rates both advanced, needing high light and CO₂.
How we compared them
A carpet is a plant that spreads sideways on runners and stays low. Some popular lawn plants, such as hairgrass and dwarf sagittaria, are grass-like and can grow much taller than a true carpet. This guide compares the carpet and lawn plants in our records with the plant pages of Tropica and Flowgrow. The two often disagree on difficulty, light and CO₂, and we say so each time. Where one of our own records differed from those pages, we went with the sourced figures.
Ratings are the sources' words, not measurements, and Tropica gives heights after two months in a tank, not final heights. Treat the order below as a starting point and check your own light and CO₂ with the plant finder.
Easier carpets and lawns
These are the plants Tropica rates easy. Tropica rates all but dwarf sagittaria as low CO₂ demand (sagittaria is medium), though Flowgrow often asks for more light and more CO₂ than Tropica does. When the two disagree, give medium light and treat the low-light claim as a minimum.
- Dwarf hairgrass (Eleocharis parvula): Tropica rates it easy, low light, low CO₂, and 3 to 10 cm or more after two months. Plant small bunches close together.
- Eleocharis acicularis is also sold as dwarf hairgrass. Tropica rates it easy, low light, low CO₂, but gives 10 to 15 cm or more after two months. Flowgrow asks for medium to high light and gives leaf lengths of 10 to 20 cm. It is a lawn you will trim, not a low carpet.
- Marsilea hirsuta: Tropica rates it easy, low light, low CO₂, medium growth. Flowgrow has no care details for it. Gensou, a plant retailer, lists it among its low-tech carpet picks. Flowgrow also says the Marsilea sold in shops are mostly labelled Marsilea crenata or M. hirsuta, that the species are hard to tell apart (the spore cases that identify them only form on plants grown out of water), and that it is unsure whether the labels are right.
- Dwarf sagittaria: Tropica rates it easy with low light. Flowgrow calls it very easy and says it grows in low to high light. It is easy, but not flat. Tropica gives 5 to 30 cm or more after two months, and Flowgrow says dense plantings can reach 60 cm while sparse ones stay at 5 to 10 cm. Tropica suggests moving it to the background if it grows too tall.
- Pygmy chain sword: the sources describe different plants. Tropica's page is for its 'Green' form, rated easy, low light, low CO₂, slow. Flowgrow's page for the species rates it medium difficulty, medium to high light and fast. We do not know whether the form explains the gap, so expect it to be somewhere between.
- Staurogyne repens: Tropica rates it easy, low light, low CO₂, medium growth. Flowgrow says easy to moderately demanding and wants medium to high light. Flowgrow says that in weak light the stems stretch and grow upright. Both advise cutting the longest shoots so that side shoots form.
Middle group: some light and some CO₂
- Monte Carlo: the sources disagree on difficulty. Tropica rates it medium with medium light and medium CO₂, and says it needs good light and added CO₂ to develop best, though it tolerates light shade. Flowgrow says easy, medium to high light, and lists CO₂ at 20 to 40 mg/l. Tropica's own HC page names Monte Carlo as the less demanding alternative, and Gensou lists it among its low-tech carpet picks, so it is a sensible first step up from the easy group.
- Marsilea minuta: Tropica rates it medium, medium light, low CO₂, a carpet 1 to 3 cm high. Flowgrow's page for the Marsilea group rates the genus easy, medium to high light, with CO₂ helpful but not required. Both say better conditions give a denser carpet. Flowgrow says M. minuta is the easiest of the group to recognise, by its smaller leaves, while the other names are muddled in the trade, as noted above.
- Brazilian micro sword: Tropica rates it easy, medium light, medium CO₂, slow. Flowgrow rates it medium, with medium growth. They agree on the main point: the dense lawn forms only under strong light, and Flowgrow adds that it must be unshaded.
- Japanese pennywort: Tropica rates it medium, medium light, low CO₂, fast, and says it makes a dense carpet in strong light and with regular pressing down. Flowgrow's page for Hydrocotyle cf. tripartita rates it easy, medium to high light and very fast, so the two disagree on difficulty. Flowgrow adds that in weaker light the shoots grow more upright than creeping, so it needs regular trimming to stay flat.
Hard group: strong light and CO₂
- HC Cuba: Tropica rates it advanced, high light, high CO₂, and says it needs circulation and fertiliser as well. Flowgrow rates it difficult, high light, and says CO₂ is not always necessary but the plant grows much healthier with it. Neither source treats it as a beginner plant.
- Glosso: Tropica rates it advanced, high light, high CO₂, and says soft water helps. Flowgrow rates it difficult with medium to high light. Flowgrow rates it fast. Tropica says it grows upwards if the light is poor, and Flowgrow says it tends to grow long in weak light.
- Utricularia graminifolia: Tropica rates it advanced, medium light, medium CO₂, and calls it rather demanding. Flowgrow rates it difficult and asks for medium to high light.
What you need for a carpet
Every carpet depends on the same few things. The harder plants need more of each.
- Light that reaches the floor. A carpet sits at the dimmest point of the tank, so a tall tank makes it harder. Check your fitting with the light finder and read the lighting section. If the leaves are small and the plant grows up instead of out, see too little light.
- CO₂ matched to the plant. Tropica says easy plants can live without added CO₂ but medium and advanced ones need it, and that CO₂ is the main thing limiting growth in a planted tank. Work out what you need with the CO₂ calculator and see the CO₂ equipment section. If you have none, stay with the easy group and read a planted tank without CO₂. If everything grows slowly at once, see slow growth from low CO₂.
- A suitable substrate. Tropica says its Helanthium makes a good carpet when the light is good and the bottom layer is nutritious, and Gensou lists a coarse substrate as a reason HC floats up. Compare options with the substrate calculator.
- Small portions, planted deep. Tropica advises small clumps a few centimetres apart for glosso and HC, and Flowgrow says the same for HC. Aquarium Co-op also says tissue-culture clumps can be split into smaller pieces before planting if you wish. Push each piece down so the roots are buried and the leaves show.
- Plenty of pieces at the start. Many plants at the start use up nutrients that algae would otherwise take (see too few plants at the start), so do not stretch a few pieces over a large floor.
- Trimming. Tropica says regular trimming is essential for HC, because the lower parts die back when the top shades them. The same logic applies to every carpet that thickens. Trim flat, and replant the cuttings into gaps.
- Patience. Retail guides give very different times, from a few weeks for HC in strong light (Flowgrow) to about 12 to 16 weeks for a low-tech carpet planted without a dry start (Gensou). Expect the slower end unless your light and CO₂ are generous.
Our beginner plant list and lighting schedule guide cover the basics, and the step-by-step setup guide shows where a carpet fits in a new tank.
Why carpets float up
Floating up is the most common carpet complaint, and it is mostly a rooting problem. Gensou lists the usual causes for HC: planting too shallow, clumps that are too big, a coarse substrate, bottom-dwelling fish that disturb the substrate, and strong flow at the substrate. The full checklist is in carpet plants floating up.
Animals matter too. One retailer guide, Indoor Ecosystem, names Amano shrimp, larger corydoras, kuhli loaches, plecos, Malaysian trumpet snails and mystery snails as animals that dig up or dislodge new carpet pieces. Check your livestock against the shrimp-safe fish and plants guide before you plant, and consider planting the carpet before you add any diggers.
Why carpets melt, and when it is not melt
Plants from tissue-culture cups are grown in a sterile gel, and Aquarium Co-op says they may melt while they adjust to your tank. Gensou adds that some melting of the old above-water leaves is normal as the plant switches to underwater growth. This is covered in new tissue-culture plants melting. Rinse the gel off, and wait for new underwater leaves.
Melt that keeps going, or a carpet that stays thin, has another cause. Gensou says melting that continues well past the first couple of weeks points to too little light or CO₂. Tropica and Flowgrow both say glosso grows long or upward in poor light, Flowgrow says Staurogyne grows upright in weak light, and both say Brazilian micro sword forms its dense lawn only under strong light. A carpet with algae on it usually has the same cause, so see the algae guide.
Which one should you choose?
- No CO₂ and a first carpet: dwarf hairgrass, Marsilea hirsuta or Staurogyne, given medium light. Add dwarf sagittaria if you do not mind height.
- A little CO₂ and decent light: Monte Carlo, a common first step up.
- Injected CO₂, strong light and time to watch the tank: HC Cuba or glosso, only after you have grown an easier carpet.
Add one carpet plant at a time, keep the routine from the weekly routine guide, and size your tank with the tank volume calculator before you count how many pieces to buy.
Keep reading
Sources
We read these pages and wrote the guide in our own words. Species, problem and tool details come from our own wiki pages linked above.
- Tropica: Micranthemum tweediei 'Monte Carlo': Medium, medium light, medium CO2, medium growth; good light and added CO2 for best growth
- Tropica: Micranthemum callitrichoides 'Cuba': Advanced, high light, high CO2, regular trimming, small clumps, suggests Monte Carlo as easier option
- Tropica: Glossostigma elatinoides: Advanced, high light, high CO2, grows upward in poor light, soft water helps, small clumps apart
- Tropica: Eleocharis parvula: Easy, low light, low CO2, 3 to 10+ cm after two months
- Tropica: Eleocharis acicularis: Easy, low light, low CO2, 10 to 15+ cm after two months
- Tropica: Marsilea minuta: Medium, medium light, low CO2, carpet 1 to 3 cm
- Tropica: Marsilea hirsuta: Easy, low light, low CO2, medium growth
- Tropica: Sagittaria subulata: Easy, low light; can grow tall
- Tropica: Fertiliser and CO2: CO2 is the main limiting nutrient; easy plants can do without, medium and advanced need it
- Tropica: Staurogyne repens: Easy, low light, low CO2, medium growth, 3 to 10+ cm; cut long shoots when planting
- Tropica: Helanthium tenellum 'Green': Easy, low light, low CO2, slow
- Tropica: Lilaeopsis brasiliensis: Easy, medium light, medium CO2, slow
- Tropica: Utricularia graminifolia: Advanced, medium light, medium CO2
- Tropica: Hydrocotyle tripartita: Medium, medium light, low CO2, fast
- Flowgrow: Sagittaria subulata: Very easy, low to high light, fast; 5 to 10 cm sparse, up to 60 cm dense
- Flowgrow: Eleocharis acicularis: Easy, medium to high light, medium growth, leaves 10 to 20 cm
- Flowgrow: Helanthium tenellum: Medium, medium to high light, fast
- Flowgrow: Staurogyne repens: Easy, medium to high light, medium growth; stems stretch in weak light, cut long stems
- Flowgrow: Utricularia graminifolia: Difficult, medium to high light, medium growth
- Flowgrow: Hydrocotyle cf. tripartita: Easy, medium to high light, very fast; more upright in weaker light
- Flowgrow: Marsilea hirsuta: No care details on the page
- Flowgrow: Micranthemum tweediei: Easy, medium to high light, CO2 20 to 40 mg/l, medium growth
- Flowgrow: Hemianthus callitrichoides 'Cuba': Difficult, high light, healthier with CO2, small patches a few cm apart
- Flowgrow: Glossostigma elatinoides: Difficult, medium to high light, fast, grows long in weak light
- Flowgrow: Marsilea spp.: Easy, medium to high light, CO2 helps; species hard to tell apart, labels unsure
- Flowgrow: Lilaeopsis brasiliensis: Medium, medium growth, dense lawn only under strong unshaded light
- Gensou: HC Cuba care guide: Retailer. Causes of floating up, trimming, persistent melt, early melt normal
- Gensou: how to grow a carpet without CO2: Retailer. Low-tech carpet picks (Monte Carlo, Marsilea hirsuta, Helanthium), time to cover
- Indoor Ecosystem: animals that harm carpets: Retailer guide, single source. Digging animals that uproot new carpet plants
- Aquarium Co-op: tissue culture plants: Adjustment period, separating clumps before planting
How we made this
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them. Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages
