Aponogeton and crinum bulbs dormant or rotting
Bulb plants such as Aponogeton and Crinum can drop all their leaves because they are resting, because the bulb was planted wrongly, or because it is rotting. A resting bulb stays firm and is worth keeping; a rotting one goes soft and should come out.
Mostly a looks problem. Fix it steadily.
Time to clear: About six to eight weeks for a rest (one source)
What you see
- All leaves die back or never appear, leaving a bare bulb
- The bulb feels firm and solid, which points to a rest
- The bulb feels soft, mushy or breaks apart, which points to rot
- A bulb buried deep with no green shoot showing
- Old leaves yellow and fade after months of good growth
Could it be something else?
- Rotting rhizome: A rhizome is a creeping stem on plants like Anubias and ferns, not a bulb, and it rots when buried
- Crypt melt: Cryptocoryne drop leaves after a change but keep their roots and usually regrow
- Tissue-culture melt: New cup plants lose their old leaves after planting, and the roots and crown stay alive
Why it happens
- A natural restMany bulb plants rest. Karen Randall says African species, including those from Madagascar, rest through a dry season, and most Asian species have a rest set off by temperature. She says A. ulvaceus needs a rest and many crispus hybrids skip it or finish a short one in the tank. Tropica says only some varieties of A. ulvaceus need a rest.
- Planted too deepTropica says a Crinum bulb should sit about half above the bottom layer. Tubers such as Aponogeton can be covered, but the growing shoot must stay above the substrate. A buried shoot cannot grow.
- Not enough stored foodA bulb needs reserves to rest and regrow. Karen Randall notes the plant must have been well fed in a rich substrate beforehand or the tuber may not have enough to sprout again.
- RotA bulb that goes soft and mushy is rotting and will not recover. We found no solid source on why aquarium bulbs rot beyond poor planting, so we do not name other causes.
Fix it now
- Lift the bulb gently and squeeze it: a firm bulb is usually alive, a soft or mushy one is rotting (our rule of thumb, not from a study)
- Remove a rotting bulb and any rotting leaves at once, as they add waste to the water
- Check that the growing tip points up and is not buried, and replant it right side up with the shoot above the substrate
- Leave a firm, resting bulb in place, or follow the rest method below if you want to move it
- To rest a bulb out of the tank, Randall stores the tuber in damp sand in a covered container in a cool place (about 60 to 65 F, 16 to 18 C) for six to eight weeks, then replants it right side up
- Once it sprouts, feed it through the roots with a rich substrate or root tabs so it can store food for next time
- Be patient: Randall says a well-fed tuber should sprout within a couple of weeks of replanting
Stop it coming back
- Plant with the shoot above the substrate and about half of a Crinum bulb out of it
- Feed bulb plants through the roots, with a rich substrate (Randall) or root tabs
- Expect a rest and leave a firm bulb alone rather than binning it
Common questions
- Is my aponogeton bulb dead or dormant?
- Squeeze it gently. A firm bulb is usually alive, even with no leaves. A soft, mushy bulb is rotting. Many Aponogeton rest, so a bare firm bulb is often just sleeping.
- How long does an aponogeton rest?
- Randall gives six to eight weeks for the rest, and Tropica gives no length. Some plants need no rest: Randall says A. rigidifolia grows from a rhizome and does not, and many crispus hybrids skip it.
- How deep should I plant an aponogeton bulb?
- Tropica says tubers can be covered but the shoot must stay above the substrate. For Crinum it advises planting about half of the bulb above the bottom layer.
- Why did my crinum lose all its leaves?
- We found no reliable source on Crinum rest or leaf loss. If the bulb is firm and planted with about half of it above the substrate, give it time and feed it through the roots.
Still stuck?
Describe the problem and share a photo in the WhatsApp community group. Other keepers can often spot what is wrong.
Sources
How we made this
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them (September 2026). Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages
Cite this page
Copy a ready-made line to credit this page in your own writing.
Citation
Scape Eden. “Aponogeton and crinum bulb dormant or rotting?”. Scape Eden aquarium wiki, updated October 15, 2026. https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/bulb-plants-dormant-or-rotting
Reference style (APA)
Scape Eden. (2026, October 15). Aponogeton and crinum bulb dormant or rotting?. Scape Eden. https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/bulb-plants-dormant-or-rotting
Plain link
https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/bulb-plants-dormant-or-rotting
Text and data compiled by Scape Eden are free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution (credit Scape Eden and link to this page). Photos keep their own credited licences. Records are AI-assisted drafts with cited sources: see how we write and check this.
