Wiki
Layout and setup

Dirted and Walstad tank problems

Also calledblackwater from soildirted tank sulphur smelldirted tank rotten egg smellpotting soil too richwalstad tank stunted plantswalstad tank low ph

A dirted (Walstad) tank has organic soil under a cap of sand or gravel. In the first weeks it can smell, stain the water yellow-brown, shift pH or leave plants small. Fish gasping or a rotten-egg smell are urgent, because the soil may be making toxic gas or the tank may be short of oxygen.

How urgentAct now

Fish or shrimp can die within hours or days.

What you see

  • A rotten-egg smell, or black patches and bubbles when the cap is disturbed
  • Fish at the surface, gasping or sluggish
  • Yellow-brown water, or cloudy water with soil in it
  • A pH reading lower than your tap water, or a test showing ammonia or nitrite
  • Plants that stay small, pale or stop growing weeks after planting

Could it be something else?

Why it happens

  1. Soil too rich or cap too thinA thin cap over nitrogen-rich soil can turn the soil sour, run short of oxygen and make toxins. A plain low-nitrogen soil without added fertiliser is the usual advice, with a cap thick enough to hold it down.
  2. Hydrogen sulphide from oxygen-free soilBacteria in soil with no oxygen make hydrogen sulphide, a gas that smells of rotten eggs and is extremely toxic to fish and shrimp. It mostly stays in the soil while an oxygen-rich layer sits at the top; if that layer is lost, the gas can reach the water.
  3. Nitrogen leaving the soilOrganic soils can release nitrogen as ammonia, and nitrogen in compost or fortified soil can take many water changes to wash out. Fish added too soon can be poisoned.
  4. Low oxygen with too many fishA Walstad tank has no aeration, so it relies on the surface and the plants. Plants make oxygen only in light, and larger fish use far more oxygen than small ones, so a crowded tank can run short, most of all overnight.
  5. Humic stain and a pH dropSoil releases humic substances that turn the water yellow-brown. Tannins from wood are only weak acids and lower pH slightly; a bigger drop points to low KH or extra CO₂.
  6. Too much light or slow settlingStrong light lets algae smother the plants. New roots also take time to settle.
Step by step

Fix it now

  1. If fish are gasping or at the surface, increase surface movement or add an air stone as a short-term rescue, and cut the number of fish if it keeps happening
  2. Avoid digging in, replanting or vacuuming the soil and cap, in case you break the oxygen-rich layer at the top
  3. Test ammonia and nitrite; if either shows with fish in the tank, read the ammonia spike guide
  4. Feed very little, because extra food clouds the water and can harm fish
  5. For brown water, add activated carbon to the filter; the colour is a stain, not a poison
  6. Cut the light to a moderate level with a midday break, so algae does not smother the plants
  7. If the smell stays strong or fish keep gasping, ask an experienced keeper or an aquatic vet, and be ready to drain the tank, remove the soil and rebuild with a plain low-nitrogen soil and a thicker cap

Stop it coming back

  • Use plain organic soil with no added fertiliser and low nitrogen, and read the bag
  • Cap the soil with sand or fine gravel thick enough to hold it down
  • Plant heavily from the start, because plants take up ammonia
  • Stock lightly with small fish, and test ammonia and nitrite as you add them
  • Pour water in gently so it does not dig into the cap

Common questions

Why does my dirted tank smell of sulphur or rotten eggs?
Bacteria in soil with no oxygen make hydrogen sulphide, which smells of rotten eggs and is extremely toxic to fish and shrimp. Avoid disturbing the soil and test ammonia. A strong smell with gasping fish is an emergency.
Is the brown water from my soil tank harmful?
No. The yellow-brown stain comes from humic substances in the soil, and tannins from wood are harmless to fish at aquarium levels. Activated carbon in the filter removes the colour.
Why is the pH low in my new Walstad jar?
Soil and wood release weak acids that lower pH only slightly, so a big drop usually means low KH or extra CO₂ from the soil. Test KH as well as pH, and test ammonia and nitrite before you add fish.
Why are my plants stunted in my Walstad tank?
A common reason is too much light feeding algae that smothers the plants. Soil that has gone sour from lack of oxygen can also hold them back. Keep the light moderate, give new roots time and plant heavily.
Scape Eden community

Still stuck?

Describe the problem and share a photo in the WhatsApp community group. Other keepers can often spot what is wrong.

Sources

  1. Aquarium Science: Walstad aquarium
  2. Aquarium Science: Wood (tannins and staining)
  3. Global Seafood Alliance: Hydrogen sulphide produced in anoxic zones can be toxic
  4. Aquarium Science: Ammonia in depth
  5. ATSDR: Hydrogen sulfide ToxFAQs

How we made this

Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them (September 2026). Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages

Cite this page

Copy a ready-made line to credit this page in your own writing.

Citation

Scape Eden. “Dirted tank problems: smell and brown water”. Scape Eden aquarium wiki, updated October 14, 2026. https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/dirted-tank-problems

Reference style (APA)

Scape Eden. (2026, October 14). Dirted tank problems: smell and brown water. Scape Eden. https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/dirted-tank-problems

Plain link

https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/dirted-tank-problems

Text and data compiled by Scape Eden are free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution (credit Scape Eden and link to this page). Photos keep their own credited licences. Records are AI-assisted drafts with cited sources: see how we write and check this.