Wiki
Shrimp and snails

Mixing shrimp species and colours (cherry, crystal red, Amano)

Also calledcan I mix shrimpcherry and crystal red togethercherry shrimp with amanowhich shrimp can live togethermixing blue pearl and yellow shrimpwill different shrimp interbreed

Some shrimp can share a tank and some cannot. Colour lines of cherry-type shrimp (Neocaridina) crossbreed and lose their colour, and cherry-type and crystal or bee shrimp (Caridina) want different water.

How urgentNot urgent

Mostly a looks problem. Fix it steadily.

What you see

  • You keep, or want to buy, two or more shrimp types or colours in one tank
  • Baby shrimp look plain brown or clear, not like their coloured parents
  • Some shrimp thrive while others in the same tank stay pale, stop breeding or die at a moult
  • You are not sure whether your shrimp are Neocaridina (cherry, blue pearl, yellow) or Caridina (crystal red, bee, Amano)

Could it be something else?

  • Shrimp colour changes: That is one shrimp looking paler or darker; here the young look different from their parents
  • Shrimp not breeding: That is about no berried females or no babies; here the question is which types to keep together

Why it happens

  1. Colour varieties crossbreedPractical Fishkeeping says the Neocaridina colour varieties crossbreed, and that mixed young go back to a plain brownish shrimp after a few generations. Do not expect blue and yellow to give a new colour; expect dull young over time.
  2. Different water needsPractical Fishkeeping describes Neocaridina as undemanding. It says bee shrimp (the Caridina group that includes crystal shrimp) prefer cooler, softer and more acidic water. Water that suits one type is a compromise for the other, and the shrimp outside its range is the one that struggles.
  3. Sensitive types in unstable waterPractical Fishkeeping calls Caridina very sensitive to changes in water chemistry, which is why it recommends slow drip acclimation for them. It also says their hardness (GH and KH) needs to be right, and that poor minerals can hold back the new shell after a moult.
  4. Some species need special conditionsPractical Fishkeeping says Sulawesi shrimp want soft but alkaline, very warm water and are not for beginners. It also says shrimp generally do better, and breed better, in a dedicated shrimp tank.
  5. Amano shrimp are different againPractical Fishkeeping says Amano shrimp mostly ignore small fish and fry, and that their young need a stage in brackish or marine water lasting weeks, so a freshwater tank will not raise Amano babies. It also says moulting suffers if the hardness (GH) is too low.
Step by step

Fix it now

Safety first: if a step uses a medicine, treatment or salt, follow the product label and never go above the labelled dose. Check the label for animals it can harm, such as shrimp, snails and scaleless fish, and for whether to remove carbon. If you are unsure, or animals keep dying, ask an aquatic vet.

  1. Find out what you have: ask the seller for the species name, because Neocaridina and Caridina need different water
  2. Keep one Neocaridina colour per tank if you want the colour to stay true; if you already mixed, accept that brown young will appear in later generations
  3. Do not put Neocaridina and Caridina in one tank unless you can give each the water it needs; keep them in separate tanks
  4. Check the tank's GH, KH, pH and temperature against what each type needs before you add anything (see the shrimp water hardness guide)
  5. Add new shrimp by slow drip acclimation
  6. Cull or separate unwanted brown young into their own tank if you want to keep a colour line pure
  7. If shrimp are already dying after you mixed types, test ammonia and nitrite and open the sudden shrimp deaths guide

Stop it coming back

  • Pick one species or colour line per tank before you buy
  • Match the water to the type you chose, not the other way round
  • Acclimate every new shrimp slowly and keep water changes small and matched
  • Keep a separate tank for sensitive or rare types

Common questions

Can I mix cherry shrimp and crystal red shrimp?
It is not a good idea. Cherry shrimp are Neocaridina and crystal red are a Caridina (bee shrimp) type, and Practical Fishkeeping says bee shrimp prefer softer, more acidic, cooler water than undemanding Neocaridina. They are different genera, so the water clash is the reason to keep them apart.
Is it okay to mix cherry shrimp with Amano shrimp?
Often yes in ordinary tanks, but check the hardness. Practical Fishkeeping calls cherry shrimp undemanding, and says Amano moult badly if the hardness (GH) is too low. Amano young need brackish or marine water to develop, so you will not get Amano babies in fresh water.
Will different coloured shrimp interbreed?
Yes if they are all Neocaridina. Practical Fishkeeping says the varieties crossbreed and the mixed young go back to a plain brownish form after a few generations. Keep one colour per tank if you want to keep the colour.
Can I keep blue pearl and yellow shrimp together?
You can, but both are Neocaridina, so they will interbreed. Practical Fishkeeping says mixed young drift back to a brownish form after a few generations, so keep them together only if you do not mind losing the colours.
Which shrimp can live together?
As a rule of thumb from the sources above, pick shrimp that need the same water, such as one Neocaridina colour plus Amano in water that is not too soft. Keep bee shrimp such as crystal red in their own tank, and keep Sulawesi shrimp for experienced keepers.
Scape Eden community

Still stuck?

Describe the problem and share a photo in the WhatsApp community group. Other keepers can often spot what is wrong.

Sources

  1. Practical Fishkeeping: an introduction to shrimp
  2. Practical Fishkeeping: Amano shrimp, spineless heroes
  3. Practical Fishkeeping: how to acclimatise your new fish or shrimp

How we made this

Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them (September 2026). Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages

Cite this page

Copy a ready-made line to credit this page in your own writing.

Citation

Scape Eden. “Can you mix shrimp? Cherry, CRS and Amano”. Scape Eden aquarium wiki, updated October 15, 2026. https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/mixing-shrimp-species

Reference style (APA)

Scape Eden. (2026, October 15). Can you mix shrimp? Cherry, CRS and Amano. Scape Eden. https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/mixing-shrimp-species

Plain link

https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/mixing-shrimp-species

Text and data compiled by Scape Eden are free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution (credit Scape Eden and link to this page). Photos keep their own credited licences. Records are AI-assisted drafts with cited sources: see how we write and check this.