Deaths when the water tests fine
Fish or shrimp die even though ammonia, nitrite and nitrate read normal. The cause is often something a test kit cannot measure: sprays, soap, metals, stray electric current, or a fish that jumped.
Fish or shrimp can die within hours or days.
What you see
- Deaths with ammonia, nitrite and nitrate all in range
- Shrimp dying first or only, while fish look mostly fine
- Fish twitching or darting wildly, then dying suddenly
- Deaths soon after insect spraying, new equipment or a new bucket
- Fish missing from the count
Could it be something else?
- Deaths after adding new fish: If you bought fish in the last few weeks, shock or disease brought in is more likely
- Low oxygen at night: Oxygen is not on a normal test kit; gasping just before the light comes on points to it
- Old tank syndrome: Deaths right after a big water change in a long-neglected tank come from the sudden change, not a toxin
Why it happens
- Insect sprays and aerosolsMosquito spray or fogging settles on the water or is pulled in with the air. It is often fatal to fish and especially shrimp at very low amounts.
- Soap, lotion and household chemicalsResidue on hands, or a bucket that once held detergent, is highly toxic to gills.
- Copper and zincCopper from pipes, some medicines and algaecides, and zinc from galvanised buckets kill shrimp and snails at very low levels and harm fish at higher ones.
- Stray voltageA failing heater, pump or powerhead can leak current into the water. Fish twitch, dart or die suddenly with no other signs, and it is a shock risk to you too.
- Jumping outA fish that jumped may be found late behind the tank, or not at all.
Fix it now
Safety first: if a step uses a medicine, treatment or salt, follow the product label and never go above the labelled dose. Check the label for animals it can harm, such as shrimp, snails and scaleless fish, and for whether to remove carbon. If you are unsure, or animals keep dying, ask an aquatic vet.
- Unplug all equipment before you put your hands in the water if fish are twitching or darting for no clear reason
- Test suspect equipment with a voltmeter and replace any heater or pump with a damaged cord or casing
- Do a large water change with dechlorinated, temperature-matched water
- Add fresh activated carbon to the filter to pull out sprays and other toxins
- Check for recent spraying, new soap or lotion, galvanised buckets, coins or copper items near the tank
- Look for a lid gap and search the floor around the tank for missing fish
Stop it coming back
- Plug all tank equipment into a residual-current device (RCD, also called a GFCI)
- Cover the tank and switch off air pumps that draw room air when anyone sprays insecticide nearby
- Rinse hands in plain water only, with no soap, before tank work
- Keep buckets and tools for the aquarium only, and use plastic, not galvanised metal
- Check medicine and fertiliser labels for copper before using them near shrimp or snails
Common questions
- I feel a tingle when I put my hand in the tank. Is that stray voltage?
- Treat any tingle as a shock risk from faulty equipment. We found no authoritative source that explains the feeling, so do not guess at the cause. Unplug all equipment at the wall before you reach in again. EHEIM's manual says not to repair an appliance yourself: return it to the maker's service facility or discard it.
- Do I need a GFCI for my aquarium?
- It is the maker's advice. EHEIM says its equipment should be protected by a residual-current device (RCD, called a GFCI in some countries) with a rated residual current of 30 mA at most, and to ask an electrician. If your sockets have none, have an electrician fit one.
- My GFCI or RCD keeps tripping. Can I just reset it?
- Do not keep resetting it. Unplug every device in the tank, keep your hands out of the water, and have an electrician check before you switch anything back on. EHEIM's manual says not to use an appliance that is leaking, damaged or not working properly.
- What if the plug or socket gets wet?
- Do not pull the plug out. Switch off the fuse or circuit breaker that supplies it first, then unplug it and check for water in the socket. Form a drip loop in every cord so water cannot run down it to the socket.
Still stuck?
Describe the problem and share a photo in the WhatsApp community group. Other keepers can often spot what is wrong.
Sources
How we made this
Written with AI assistance from the sources listed here and checked against them (September 2026). Not yet reviewed by an expert. Report a mistake · How we write and check pages
Cite this page
Copy a ready-made line to credit this page in your own writing.
Citation
Scape Eden. “Fish dying but water tests fine: causes”. Scape Eden aquarium wiki, updated October 15, 2026. https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/deaths-water-tests-fine
Reference style (APA)
Scape Eden. (2026, October 15). Fish dying but water tests fine: causes. Scape Eden. https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/deaths-water-tests-fine
Plain link
https://scapeeden.com/wiki/problems/deaths-water-tests-fine
Text and data compiled by Scape Eden are free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution (credit Scape Eden and link to this page). Photos keep their own credited licences. Records are AI-assisted drafts with cited sources: see how we write and check this.
